When the light doesn’t help you, the background becomes even more important. Why? Because it can save or destroy how the image is perceived.
If you have a decently lit subject and behind it:
aggressively colored boards,
chaotic spectators,
uneven shadows,
very bright areas,
then the image becomes hard to read.
a darker background
a simple background
an even background
areas without odd patches of light
Sometimes moving a little to the left or right does more than any camera setting.